Sunday Newsletter

Masses Today

6.30: Joseph & Esther Crane and family, (Anniv).
11.00: Nora Duggan, (Anniv).
6.30: Pauline & John Ryan, (Anniv).

As I Was Saying...

A constant theme at any clerical gathering these days is "low morale" and "disillusionment". Clerical scandals, especially the sexual abuse of children by a relatively small number of their clerical, have taken a heavy toll of clerical self-esteem. Many clergymen harbour a morbid fear of false allegations. While the actual number of false allegation have been miniscule, nevertheless, some spectacular miscarriages of justice have resulted.

It is of course a criminal offence to falsely accuse someone of sexual abuse. To my knowledge just two such prosecutions have reached the courts. The priest-victim in one of these cases was a priest from the archdiocese of Dublin and a friend of mine. He was a caring, conscientious man with wonderful leadership qualities. Then, out of the blue, a Paul Anderson walks into a Garda station in West Dublin and claimed that he had been sexually abused by this priest. The priest was immediately asked to 'stand aside' by Church authorities.

Four years later, Paul Anderson is convicted of making these false allegations and sentenced to four years in prison. But the priest's life had already been destroyed. Here is an extract from his 'victim impact' statement read to the court:

"As I said at the outset, and I repeat again: I would honestly have preferred if the perpetrator had shot me through the head rather than put me and my family through the pangs of anxiety and the profound sufferings we have endured over the last four years.

When he went with One-in-Four to Archbishop's House armed with his accusation it hair-triggered the church's guidelines - with immediate devastating effect on me and on the practice of my priesthood.

I was instantly and publicly suspended from my ministry. So without any due process, my diocese, in this Guantanamo Bay reaction, had me stand aside from my work as a priest. I had to leave my home and stay with family and friends and I lost almost a year out of my pastoral work."

It is an extraordinary dilemma for the church. Does the church allow a priest continue in his ministry in the light of unproven allegations, or do they suspend him immediately from his pastoral work? If they don't suspend, they face accusations of not taking child abuse seriously, allowing a potential molester to keep on molesting. If they immediately suspend a priest who may be innocent, are they not guilty of a rush to judgement and actually destroying the life of a good and caring man, as happened above, obviously?

Such situations have sapped the morale of many priests, leaving them feeling isolated and vulnerable. The priests' 'Trade Union', if you like, is the National Conference of the Priests. This is an elected body that kept an eye out for the interests and welfare of priests, and ably represented those interests to the bishops. This week, at their AGM in Athlone, the National Conference of Priests voted themselves out of existence. No reason was given. Obviously, the low clerical morale has made its way to the higher echelons. What a great pity!

-Dick Lyng


Items of Some Interest


Top

Valid HTML 4.01 Strict