Sunday Newsletter

Masses Today

6.30: Bryan Flaherty, (Anniv).
11.00: Stephen Concannon, (Anniv).
6.30: Joe Dolan, Bowling Green, (Anniv).

AS I WAS SAYING.....

The French daily newspaper France Soir this week published a cartoon depicting the founders of the main religions - Buddhism, Judaism, Islam and Christianity - sitting on a cloud. Jesus is saying: "Stop complaining, Muhammad - we have all been caricatured here." This newspaper was the first in France to reproduce the 12 Danish cartoons representing the Prophet Muhammad and lampooning Islam's intolerance. This provoked outrage in the world of Islam.

But Alain Woodrow, writing in this week's Tablet, makes the point that caricatures, even bad ones, are excessive by nature in their aim to deflate intolerance, Puritanism and pomposity. So should believers be worried when their faith is debunked? After all, humour can be the first step to humility, he points out. Freedom of speech is a principle worth protecting.

But this is a complex issue. How do you demonstrate your principles? Take the principle of democracy. Supposing someone suggested that, to show the rest of the world how democratic we are, there should be a day when at polling stations throughout the western world everybody could vote Yes or No to the question: Do you believe in democracy?

Most people would condemn that as a futile and irritating, degrading rather than commending democracy. How, then, do you demonstrate the principle of freedom of speech? By embarking on an equally futile and irritating diversion such as publishing inflammatory cartoons just to prove you can?

What the French satirical magazine, Charlie Ebdo, did this week is a far cry from the more naive action of the Danish newspaper which originally printed the offensive cartoons three months ago. There's no good reason for any press to re-publish material proven to incite violent demonstrations. It seems to me to be a wholly gratuitous exercise.

One wonders whether the same publication would be as quick to print cartoons satirising the suffering of Jews in the Holocaust, the mental agony of people who have been sexually abused or the restricted mobility of Nelson Mandela. I write as someone who loves cartoons. They are far more effective than words in challenging received perceptions. But subversive depiction is not limited to the Charlie Ebdo's of the world. It's also a feature of the Christian Gospels, not that Jesus drew cartoons, but he did know the value of cameo stories which could turn received wisdom on its head.

The most famous of these cameos is the parable of the Good Samaritan, in which the maligned and mistrusted foreigner becomes the compassionate benefactor. Another similar and eminently cartoonable story is that of two men praying in the temple. In it, God takes more notice of the faltering phrases of a guilt-ridden tax collector than the practised platitudes of a prince of religion. What is it which ultimately heals the world - the demonisation of what many people call sacred purely to illustrate the principle of free speech, or the recognition of virtue in people who are routinely derided? If principles of justice are being weighed, will the scales tip in favour of Charlie Ebdo or the Good Samaritan?

-Dick Lyng


St. Augustine's Parish

'MOTHER OF ALL PARTIES'

On Friday 17th February 7.30pm for 8.00pm
in
The Ardilaun Hotel
(Celebrating our return to St. Augustine's)
Tickets (€15)
Available after all Masses today &
In Priory Office during the week


A VALENTINE ANTIDOTE

(The Victorians specialised in deflating romance through use of satire. Valentine's Day was an obvious target. This is a Valentine Card from 1885. Pass it on!)

Old and ugly, mean and stupid,
What a chance are you for Cupid!
Die when you may, this truth I tell,
Old Beelzebub will toll the bell.
Tho' men have long o'erlook'd your charms,
You'll fill old Satan's glowing arms.


Items of Interest


Valid HTML 4.01 Strict